A coalition of roughly two dozen states led by California sued the Trump administration on October 2, 2026, to block a rollback of federal fuel economy standards. The new rules cut the 2031 target for new cars and light trucks to an average of 34.9 mpg, far below the 50.4 mpg set under President Biden, and they will shape what American drivers pay for cars and for gas over the next decade.
- The rule: The Transportation Department now requires a fleet average of 34.9 mpg for model year 2031, down from 50.4 mpg under the previous standard.
- The lawsuit: California, New York and other states, joined by Democratic-led cities, say the rule breaks federal law. Environmental groups filed a separate challenge.
- The administration’s case: It says the change will cut the average price of a new car by $1,289 by 2031.
- The critics’ case: Drivers would spend about $1,624 more on fuel over time compared with the Biden rules, according to figures reported by The New York Times.
- Backdrop: U.S. gasoline prices are up about 30% in 2026, partly because of the conflict with Iran.
[IMAGE 1: Close-up of a gas pump nozzle in a car at a U.S. fuel station]
What the fuel economy rollback changes
Fuel economy rules, known as Corporate Average Fuel Economy (CAFE) standards, are set by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). They require each automaker’s lineup of new vehicles to meet an average miles-per-gallon target. Automakers can sell some thirstier models as long as more efficient ones bring the average up.
The new rule lowers the 2031 target to 34.9 mpg. According to Al Jazeera, part of the change comes from recalculating the baseline fleet in a way that leaves out electric vehicles already on the road. Critics argue that method makes today’s fleet look less efficient than it is, which in turn justifies a lower goal.
A separate change takes effect in model year 2030. More than 100 crossover nameplates, including the Toyota RAV4, Honda CR-V and Ford Bronco Sport, will move from the light truck group to the passenger car group, according to The Auto Channel’s weekly industry roundup. That shift puts those models under different efficiency benchmarks.
| Measure | Biden-era rule | New rule |
|---|---|---|
| Fleet average target, model year 2031 | 50.4 mpg | 34.9 mpg |
| Claimed effect on new car price by 2031 | Not applicable | $1,289 lower on average (administration estimate) |
| Estimated extra fuel cost for drivers | Not applicable | About $1,624 more over time (reported by The New York Times) |
Why the states are suing
Federal law says NHTSA must set fuel economy standards at the “maximum feasible” level. The states argue the new rule fails that test. They say the 2031 standard would ask less of automakers than the industry already achieves and ignores recent progress in electric and hybrid technology.
Reports differ on the details of the filing. Al Jazeera put the coalition at 26 states led by California and New York, while The New York Times, as carried by GV Wire, described nearly two dozen states plus cities and said the case was filed in the 1st U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. A second lawsuit from groups including the Environmental Defense Fund and Public Citizen was filed in federal court in Washington, D.C., according to Al Jazeera.
The challenge may have limited practical bite in the short term. Congress has already eliminated the fines automakers paid for missing the targets, which weakens enforcement whatever the court decides.
What automakers and the administration say
Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy has framed the rollback as a way to make new cars cheaper. The department has also said the change could save taxpayers $138 billion over five years, according to Al Jazeera.
Some automakers welcomed the move. Shane Karr of Stellantis North America said the company supported resetting the rules to “more achievable targets.” Shares of Ford, GM and Toyota fell about 1% on the day of the lawsuit, while Stellantis dropped more than 6%, Al Jazeera reported.
[IMAGE 2: Row of new SUVs and crossovers parked at a U.S. car dealership lot]
What it means for car buyers
The fight lands at a hard moment for buyers. Gasoline averaged about $4.43 a gallon in the third quarter, and drivers are shifting toward hybrids and fuel-efficient models, according to The Auto Channel’s roundup. The combined U.S. market share of GM, Ford and Stellantis fell to about 36% in the third quarter, a record low by that account.
Lower standards may help automakers keep prices down on trucks and large SUVs. Large SUVs already average more than $67,000, according to The Auto Channel’s roundup. But they also reduce pressure to make every vehicle more efficient. For a household that drives a lot, higher fuel bills could outweigh a lower sticker price over the life of the car. AAA puts the average yearly cost of owning a new vehicle at $12,863.
In practice, buyers will not see the effect overnight. Model year 2031 vehicles are still years away, and automakers plan their lineups long in advance. For now, fuel prices and the shift toward hybrids are likely to matter more to shoppers than the legal fight. Our earlier look at why lower-priced new cars are gaining popularity covers the same affordability pressures.
What happens next
The court will first decide whether the case can go forward and on what schedule. Until then, the new standard remains in place unless a judge blocks it.
Automakers are also cutting back on new launches. Only about 9% of lineups are expected to be redesigned between 2026 and 2028, down from a 14% average, according to the same industry roundup. That suggests the cars on dealer lots will change slowly regardless of how the lawsuit ends.
FAQ
What is the new U.S. fuel economy standard?
New cars and light trucks must average 34.9 mpg by model year 2031, down from the 50.4 mpg target set under the Biden administration.
Who is suing over the rollback?
A group of roughly two dozen states led by California, plus several cities. Environmental groups including the Environmental Defense Fund and Public Citizen filed a separate case.
Will new cars get cheaper?
The administration estimates the average new car will cost $1,289 less by 2031. Critics say drivers will pay more in fuel over time. Neither figure is guaranteed.
